Ludicom

Wireless => Competitive Battling => Topic started by: Scarlet Spider on February 16, 2014, 07:10:10 pm



Title: Smogon XY Round 1 Test Bans
Post by: Scarlet Spider on February 16, 2014, 07:10:10 pm
Quote
   

    Voting phase is over, here are the results of the vote:

    Lucarionite: 125 Ban, 8 Do Not Ban, 3 Abstain -> Uber with a 94% majority

    Genesect: 77 Ban, 48 Do Not Ban, 11 Abstain -> Uber with a 61.6% majority

    Deoxys-S: 44 Ban, 75 Do Not Ban, 17 Abstain-> OU with a 63% majority

    Users eligible to vote: 145

    Actual voters: 136

    The verdict of the test is that Lucarionite and Genesect achieved the required supermajority and are, therefore, banned to Ubers with immediate effect. Deoxys-S remains OU.


Deoxys-S stays in OU which is fine
Genesect got banned by a small majority, I think it'd be more fair if they did it as supermajorities (66%) whether the mon is broken or not.
MegaLucario banned to Ubers, was too much it seems (added to the banned mega pile with Gengar and Kangaskhan which were quickbans rather than rounds)


Title: Re: Smogon XY Round 1 Test Bans
Post by: Kinfin on February 16, 2014, 07:27:21 pm
Deoxys-S stays in OU which is fine
Genesect got banned by a small majority, I think it'd be more fair if they did it as supermajorities (66%) whether the mon is broken or not.
MegaLucario banned to Ubers, was too much it seems (added to the banned mega pile with Gengar and Kangaskhan which were quickbans rather than rounds)
Long as Mega Mawile is safe.


Title: Re: Smogon XY Round 1 Test Bans
Post by: RIIKYUUUN~<3 on February 16, 2014, 07:45:18 pm
Long as Mega Mawile is safe.
I don't think Megamawile is in any danger of being Uber'd so long as Huge Power Diggersby is alive


Title: Re: Smogon XY Round 1 Test Bans
Post by: DarkDragon on February 17, 2014, 05:38:59 am
Happy about Lucarionite, that thing was almost impossible to wall.

A bit iffy about Genesect, granted it was very good but I don't think it was broken tbh.

Yeah glad Deoxys-S is still OU Defog hurt it a lot.


Title: Re: Smogon XY Round 1 Test Bans
Post by: Scarlet Spider on February 17, 2014, 06:06:23 am
Happy about Lucarionite, that thing was almost impossible to wall.

A bit iffy about Genesect, granted it was very good buy I don't think it was broken tbh.

Yeah glad Deoxys-S is still OU Defog hurt it a lot.
yeah Genesect didn't look too much of an issue due to power creep.

Long as Mega Mawile is safe.
Mawile will be fine, it looks like a nice solidly OU mon that's great but not broked